Socialist Action

 

SOCIALIST

ACTION

 

 - home page

 - newspaper
 - subscribe
 - distribute

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Eyes Wide Open

by Gaetana Caldwell-Smith  /  June 2007 issue of Socialist Action newspaper

 

"Civic Duty," directed by Jeff Renfroe, written by Andrew Joiner, starring Peter Krause, Kari Matchett, Khaled Abol Naga, and Peter Schiff.

 

It’s not too long after 9/11. Because of a failing economy, accountant Terry Allen (Peter Krause), a bland, white guy, loses his job as an accountant for a large corporation. Coincidently, on the same day the Homeland Security Advisory System is raised to Orange. Everywhere signs abound advising people to report anything suspicious, while Fox and CNN broadcast Bush’s terrorist warnings and the ever-changing Homeland Security Advisories.

 

Terry’s normally upbeat wife, Marie (Kari Mattchett), now hassles him about the new house they were in the middle of buying and complains about bills. One sleepless night, Allen peeks out his apartment window. He sees the new tenant, Gabe Hassan (Egyptian actor Khaled Abol Naga), dumping a huge trash-bag of garbage. Suspicious!

 

As the days go on, not only does Allen suspect his neighbor of being a terrorist, he believes the guy is coming on to his wife. One day, he spies several men, who also appear to be Middle Eastern, enter Gabe’s apartment, carrying small boxes. He can’t just sit there and let whatever happens happen, so he calls the FBI. Agent Hillary (a dour Richard Schiff, formerly of the "West Wing" TV series) basically tells Allen to mind his own business.

 

But Allen decides to take things into his own hands. Like an interrogator at Abu Ghraib or

Guantanamo, Allen imprisons Hassan in the guy's own apartment and grills him at gunpoint.

 

Director Renfroe films the tragic final scenes between the Allens, Hassan, Hillary, and a raft of armed FBI agents in fast-paced, spliced shots as though the gripping action were seen in a fractured mirror or through a huge kaleidoscope. He and writer Andrew Joiner could easily have ended "Civic Duty" with a cliché. Thankfully, they didn’t. Rather, it is unexpected.

 

But they did tack on a scene showing that Allen’s ordeal had cracked through his fragile psyche, and he ends up in a psychiatric facility.

 

In an interview last month in the San Francisco Chronicle, actor Peter Krause said he believes that "the corporate-led government has led us to the place where we’re at now." Krause was involved in the rewrite of "Civic Duty" and says that the film is a harsh indictment of fear mongering since 9/11, and he wants the media to "get called out for jerking the public into a state of paranoia."

 

He said that he rewrote his character, Terry Allen, from a "Bush-loving" loyal to that of a bipartisan average guy who trusts the media and politicians. He feels that, though six years have passed since 9/11, the government reaction to recent thwarted terrorist plots and the Virginia Tech shooting is an example that repeats a post-9/11 message: "Keep an eye on our citizens. They may be dangerous." He hopes "Civic Duty" will make people ask questions.

 

During this interview, Krause seemed to have an inflated idea that his film is on a par with Michael Moore’s, or that he and Renfroe would be marginalized as left-wing propagandists. Not even close.

 

In the first place, Renfroe’s film is fiction, and unfortunately, judging by the box office take since it opened, compared to Moore’s documentaries and Oliver Stone’s fictional films, "Civic Duty" is a dud.

 

Yet, "Civic Duty" does raise issues that aren’t usually discussed in popular media. It makes us aware that corporations manipulate us through media in bed with the U.S. government. Our government wants people to be fearful and suspicious—while drums beat for Iran as they did for Iraq.                                                       

 

Human Needs, Not Profits!