Socialist Action

 

SOCIALIST

ACTION

 

 - home page

 - newspaper
 - subscribe
 - distribute

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Water, Water Everywhere . . .

by Gaetana Caldwell-Smith  / May 2008

 

 
"Flow: For Love of Water" is a beautifully filmed documentary about the corporate takeover of the world's water supply. Gorgeous scenes of naturally flowing water are interspersed throughout by cinematographer Pablo de Selva and director Irena Salina—a dramatic contrast to water-deprived areas.


The international cast of scientists, ecology activists, and writers interviewed for the film believe fights over water rights will trump the current oil wars. Advocates for water rights for Third World  countries, where two million children die of water-born diseases annually, speak on what must be done to ensure clean, fresh water not only for those populations but for everyone.


Scientist and internationally known water expert Dr. Peter Gleick explains the water cycle we all learned in grammar school. With a nod to Al Gore's film, "Inconvenient Truth," environmental scientists believe that global warming has caused erratic changes to this cycle, resulting in water scarcity, droughts, floods, and crop failure—and leading to famine and starvation. These changes can cause lakes and rivers to dry up in certain areas, reducing the amount of water evaporation, and bringing on unpredictable rainfall seasons.  Instead, there are devastating deluges, causing floods and washing away precious topsoil.


In "Flow," Dr. Gleick and UC Berkeley biologist Tyrone Hayes state that it is a fallacy to believe that the water supply in the U.S. is safe to drink or bathe in. Our water contains pesticides that leach through our pores each time we shower. A recent discovery is that tap water in the developed world also contains pharmaceuticals from pills (or residue from urine) flushed down toilets or dumped into landfills. As yet, there is no way to filter out these drugs.


Hayes  went on to say that the pesticide atrazine, manufactured by Syngenta, in Sweden, was banned outright by the EU, yet Syngenta sells it to the U.S. According to Hayes, U.S. big agro uses it on two-thirds of all the corn, sorgum, and soy-bean fields; 90 percent of sugarcane fields; and municipalities spray it on lawns, golf courses, and Christmas tree farms. Vandana Shiva, a physicist and ecologist from India, talks about the plight of babies born with birth defects because their mothers had drunk ground water ruined by pesticides.


In one startling scene, the camera focuses on a sluggish, blood-red stream near a small village in Africa. Maude Barlow, chairperson of the Council of Canadians, who was involved with the 2003 documentary, "Corporation," approaches the stream with villagers who tell her that blood from a nearby slaughterhouse is channeled into the river. Downstream, people drink the water, bathe, and wash clothes in it because they don't have access to clean water, and many sicken and die.


In her interview for "Flow" and in her book, "Blue Gold," Barlow says that the buying and selling of water will become as controversial as the oil business today. She equates the current fresh water supply with that of oil reserves.


In Africa, women and children stand in long lines, waiting to fill containers from a spigot in the ground, controlled by France’s Suez Corporation. Sometimes "they" allow water to flow twice a day, sometimes once.  Sometimes people wait all day for water. Other Suez-controlled sources require the insertion of a coin and people have to decide whether to buy food or water.


"Flow" includes clips from a documentary film about the victory in Cochabamba, Bolivia, over water privatization, led by activist and protest leader Oscar Olivera. Activist/author Jim Schultz, founder of the Democracy Center based in Cochabamba, provided a voiceover. Interviewed, Schultz reveals that in 1997 the World Bank forced Cochabamba's water privatization by Aguas del Tunari, a private company owned by London-based International Water Ltd. The people in Cochabamba couldn't afford to buy the privatized water; the costs had risen beyond their means. Several people demonstrating against the privatization were killed by Bolivian police and the military. Still, they prevailed and won.

"Flow" makes clear that the "water business" is not just a Third World problem. The Nestlés Corporation built a water bottling plant in Michigan to bottle water pumped by the hundreds of gallons a day from nearby rivers and aquifers. It’s a ridiculous situation, says Sweetwater Alliance member, Michigan resident, and author, Holly Wren Spaulding. Nestlés bottles this water, ships it all over the U.S., imports it, and sells it back to Michigan residents.


The townspeople, led by attorney Jim Olson, brought a suit against Nestlés to shut it down. They succeeded to a degree. Nestlés agreed to reduce the number of thousands of gallons it pumps per day. But the people are still working with Olson to shut it down, permanently.


As Shri Rajendra Singh, a cheerful Indian activist, tells it in "Flow," a Suez Corp. official told him that water from streams and rivers around his village was not his. Rain was not his. Singh could only laugh.


In 1985, Singh and an NGO official, Tarun Bharat Sangh, traveled to Alwar, a poor province in India. Water was scarce, cattle were dying on parched land declared by the Indian government as a hopeless Black Zone. "Flow" documents Singh's work with villagers. With a local elder's advice, Singh organized them and restored old "johads" (water harvesting structures), a simple, yet labor-intensive, years-long project.


Today, two decades later, there are 8600 "johads" in over a thousand villages spread over 6500 square km. A beautiful shot by de Selva and Salina shows a paradisiacal scene of a pond, trees, birds, and enough running water to grow food. The people Singh had trained have gone to other villages to create more watersheds.


Vandana Shiva strongly urges people to speak out and march, as they did in Bolivia and are still doing in Michigan, or to protest silently. It worked in Kerala, India.

 

Human Needs, Not Profits!