Socialist Action

 

SOCIALIST

ACTION

 

 - home page

 - newspaper
 - subscribe
 - distribute

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The Old Man & the Puppy:

Eyewitness to the 2nd Battle of Falujah

by Ross Caputi  / November 2007 issue of Socialist Action newspaper

 

 

The author, a former Marine, participated in the second battle of Fallujah and gives us this eyewitness report. The city, containing over 200,000 people, suffered extensive damage in the U.S.-Iraqi attack.

 

According to some reports, perhaps half the homes were damaged, and about 60 mosques were destroyed. The Red Cross estimated that over 800 civilians were killed.  The second battle of Fallujah, in November 2004, has been called Operation Phantom Fury and Al-Fajr [“The Dawn”]. But those of us who where there simply called it “The City.”

 

Since Operation Vigilant Resolve, our first attempt to pacify the city, in April 2004, all coalition forces had been withdrawn from the city. In the following six months Fallujah became a hot bed of insurgent activity. Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, an insurgent leader and high priority target for the U.S., was believed to be operating out of Fallujah. With the upcoming national elections in Iraq and Zarqawi in Fallujah, the U.S. military launched a second attempt to capture the city.

 

Like most of the units that were called up for the second battle, we had been doing routine convoys for American contractors for the past five months. Nobody in my unit had even fired a shot yet. Occasionally, Intel would give us the location of a high-profile target, and we got to cordon off the area and kick the door in. Nine out of 10 times there was nobody in the house but women and children.

 

“This is my rifle. There are many like it, but this one is mine,” our drill instructors used to make us shout. “It is my life. I must master it as I must master my life. Without me my rifle is useless.  Without my rifle I am useless.” This was pounded into our heads over and over again.

 

The rifleman’s creed was just one of many tools used to mold and shape us into the same Marine—proud, selfless, and violent. We were trained to defend freedom by means of war, and never question orders, like interchangeable parts of the war machine. Without combat our rifles were useless. We were useless.

 

We had become disillusioned with our missions and were growing restless for action. But tomorrow would be different. We would finally get a chance to use our rifles and all our months of training and preparation would not be in vain. We could finally prove ourselves as warriors and defend the nation that we all loved.

 

[Marine battalion commander] Lt. Colonel Gareth Brandl addressed us, his men, in front of an assortment of generals and news crews. He told us to expect 2000 to 3000 hardcore insurgents when we entered the city. We were also told that the civilians had evacuated the city. When questioned about the possibility of civilian casualties Lt. Colonel Brandl said, “The competence and compassion of my Marines will mitigate any civilian casualties.”

 

After that we were taken aside and given a second brief. Our commanders told us to expect 50 percent casualties on our side. They explained to us how things would happen tomorrow, and informed us of a new change in our rules of engagement. Because the civilians had moved out, we were to shoot anyone with a weapon in their hands.

 

The next morning we loaded up into trucks and headed for the city. I could see the smoke rising on the other side of the desert. We passed a mother dressed in all black with her two small children wandering across the desert. I wondered how many more there were in the same situation or worse. I suddenly felt ridiculous for assuming that these people could just pick up and leave their city. What about the old and sick? Where would they go? How long could they wander in the desert?

 

That night over 10,000 U.S. troops waited outside the city and watched a fireworks show of military supremacy as we pounded that city with every bomb in our arsenal, and even a little white phosphorous for effect. I wondered if the air support got their targets from the same flawed Intel from which we got ours.

 

The battle officially began on Nov. 7. A few days later, AAVs dropped us off by the mayor’s complex in the heart of the city. It was early morning and still dark. We cleared our first three buildings without seeing any signs of life or resistance.

 

The sun began to rise over the beautiful Blue Mosque as we reached the roof of the police station. Morning Prayer began to echo from loudspeakers across the city. When the final words were sung the first burst of machine gun fire could be heard in the distance.

 

Machine gun fire answered back and forth and the beautiful sounds of war erupted all over the city; officers barking commands over their radios, machine gun bursts roaring in the distance, RPGs hissing by, grenades detonating, and Marines shouting.

 

Fallujah quickly became violent and chaotic. The adrenaline infected us like fever, distorting reality and all sense of right and wrong. We became bloodthirsty maniacs as we pushed through the city.

 

Rumors started to spread about a Marine in 3rd Platoon that already had five kills. When we learned that most of the insurgents were carrying large amounts of international currencies on them we began going through the pockets of every dead body like scavengers.

 

From Morning Prayer until sundown we would fight, and as soon as night came it was silent. Not a single gunshot or even a whisper for the entire night. Every night we would occupy a different house; some were nearly destroyed by artillery and air strikes while others still had family photos hanging on the wall. We slept in their beds, ate whatever food we could find, and helped ourselves to trinkets and souvenirs.

 

After five days of battle everyone was used to the sight of dead bodies and blood. Nothing seemed strange anymore. We no longer flinched at the sound of gunfire or batted an eye at a severed limb. It was at this point that things started to get out of control.

 

One Marine slit a puppy’s throat because he couldn’t stand its crying. Another Marine opened up a dead body like a cadaver to search for the adrenal gland. Anyone who objected was afraid to speak up. The sickness that had taken hold of us had become too dangerous. All rules of war had gone out the window.

 

Some became cold and were unaffected by all things good and bad around them. Others lashed out in anger.  When the old man was killed nobody even seemed to notice. The squad that shot him said that they couldn’t tell what was in his hands. It was prayer beads. His body was left just as it fell and we moved on.

 

When we where able to see the desert we knew that we were close to the end of the city. We occupied a small house that would become our firm base for the next few weeks. I was physically and emotionally exhausted.  The adrenaline had worn off and my mind was coming back to reality. Thoughts of the old man and the puppy ran through my head like a slide show. I was glad that I had not committed any of these acts myself, but I felt guilty by association.

 

I looked at the pictures still hanging on the walls of the family that had once lived here. Were they lucky enough to make it out of this God-forsaken city to wander hopelessly in the desert? I wanted to throw down my rifle and quit; it no longer defined me. It seemed sadly ironic to me that someone decided to name this war Operation Iraqi Freedom. It was all too absurd and I no longer believed in my purpose there.  An entire city destroyed and its people displaced and murdered—all in the name of freedom.

 

Human Needs, Not Profits!