Socialist Action

 

SOCIALIST

ACTION

 

 - home page

 - newspaper
 - subscribe
 - distribute

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Haitian Refugees Face ‘Apartheid’

by Marty Goodman  /  May 2007 issue of Socialist Action Newspaper

 

    

The treatment of 101 Haitian refugees who came ashore March 28 in Hallandale, Fla., has re-ignited community anger at racist immigration policies. After spending 22 days at sea in an overcrowded boat, and suffering from 12 days without food and water, the refugees were seized by U.S. immigration authorities and, after brief medical attention, quickly sent to detention centers like criminals.  

 

During the landing, one refugee, Lifaite Lully (24), able to swim but too weakened by the journey, drowned.

 

The adults were sent to facilities in Palm Beach County. Thirteen Haitian minors, arriving without parents, were sent to altogether different holding locations in Miami, despite family and friends waiting to receive them in that city. The 101 Haitians face expedited hearings and deportation, despite the Bush administration's warnings to U.S. citizens to not travel to Haiti given increased violence there.

 

After a 2002 change in immigration policy, refugees who arrive by sea, except Cubans, are subject to an accelerated deportation procedure, usually after two weeks. As of this writing (April 24), the asylum interviews have begun.  

 

Since 1981, U.S. immigration policy has regarded Haitian refugees as "economic," not "political" refugees, despite the volatile Human Rights situation in Haiti. In stark contrast, anti-Communist exiles, such as the mostly white Cuban exiles, have received almost automatic political asylum upon entering the U.S. and are quickly released into the community. Known as the "wet foot/dry foot" policy, Cubans interdicted on the high seas by the U.S. Coast Guard are also returned to Cuba, but may persuade U.S. officials to grant them entry.

 

Haitian advocates are demanding "Temporary Protected Status" (TPS) for the 101 refugees in order to prepare for their hearings. TPS is awarded other refugee groups, such as Hondurans, Nicaraguans, and Salvadorans, for natural disasters and political violence, but not to Haitians.   

 

Reflecting the broad opposition to Haitian policy, Archbishop of Miami, John C. Favalora, said that Haitians face "apartheid" when arriving by sea compared to Cubans and called for the release of all the refugees.

 

An angry protest on March 31, sponsored by the Haitian political organization Ve Ye Yo, was held at U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services in Miami, and attended by several hundred Haitians and supporters.

 

A prominent speaker was the Rev. Gerard Jean-Juste, a former political prisoner in Haiti, who headed the Haitian Refugee Center of Miami in the 1980s. Jean-Juste said immigration policy was not "wet foot" and "dry foot" but "black foot" and "white foot." "Black foot, white foot, we are all human beings!" he told the rally.

 

Henry Petithomme, a Haitian living in Miami, began a hunger strike to dramatize the refugees’ plight and received wide attention. After, consuming only water and sport drinks, he ended his strike on April 18 in relatively good health.

 

On April 21, some 1200, mostly Haitians, attended  a memorial for the drowned Lifaite Lully at Notre Dame Catholic Church in Little Haiti. In an angry, impassioned eulogy Haitian Reverend Reginald Jean-Mary shouted out, "They are not criminals, they are human beings. Instead of giving them dignity, we imprison them and treat them like dogs, like trash. America, you forget where you come from."

 

The refugees are scheduled to be heard by Judge Rex  J. Ford, who has denied 88.5% of all asylum requests and 97.6% of all Haitian asylum cases, making him one of the country’s most anti-immigrant judges. Even so, many Haitians are reluctant to appeal deportation orders anyway out of a fear of being transferred to far-away, isolated detention facilities during the lengthy appeals process.

 

For Haitians living "legally" in South Florida, there has been an unprecedented number of spouses and children seized and deported back to Haiti—even as appeals are pending. Immigration officials have given the deportations the code name, "Return to Sender."

 

In recent years the racist policy was made crueler for Haitians. Since December 2001, a secret "national security" measure issued to the Department of Homeland Security, which operates ICE (formerly INS), directed it to block the release of Haitian refugees from detention, although no link has ever been made to Haitians and terrorism.

 

In 2002, then Attorney General John Ashcroft ordered 200 Haitians who had arrived in Miami by boat to remain in detention as a threat to "national security," even though some were already granted asylum or bonds by judges. In Senate hearings, Ashcroft singled out Haitians as a security risk.

 

Historically, both Republican and Democratic administrations have denied asylum rights to Haitians, in violation of U.S. and international law, including the 1967 UN Protocol on Refugees signed by the U.S. Deportation to Haiti frequently resulted in persecution, sometimes death. The deportations continued through the end of the 29-year Duvalier family dictatorship in 1986, and during the U.S.-backed post-Duvalier military juntas.

 

Under Bush Sr. and Bill Clinton, the deportations continued during the brutal CIA-sponsored Haitian military government of 1991-1994.

 

To understand Haitian emigration today one must take a hard look at U.S. policy. Washington has backed endless despotic regimes in Haiti, run by tiny elites. That relationship, mixed with racism, has been reinforced by a U.S. military occupation in 1915 and U.S.-led UN occupations in 1994 and in 2004, which continues today.   

 

Today, most Haitians live on less than $1 a day; the economy is in shambles. Yet, Washington insists that Haiti follow the starvation "free trade" economic policies of the World Bank. Truly, Haiti is ripe for revolution. 

Human Needs, Not Profits!